# Codex is 1st of 6 on code review, the reviewer Claude Code users call in

*Codex ranks 1st of six coding agents on code reviews that find real issues. On Reddit, 45.5% of the people who praise those reviews also post in a Claude forum, against 9.9% (1,862 of 18,816) of other Codex judges. The pull runs the other way too, but much more weakly.*

What users credit, OpenAI Codex. By Feedback Bench, 14 November 2026. Feedback Bench 1.1. Posts 31 August 2026 to 8 November 2026. Web: https://feedbackbench.com/coding-agents/#/articles/codex-is-1st-of-6-on-code-review-the-reviewer-claude-code-users-call-in

In October a developer on r/codex who builds with Claude described a small piece of wiring they had added, and what it was worth to them:

> i've setup a cross review skill so claude opus 5.5 can ask codex sol 6.1 xhigh for a review of the code changes and it seems to catch quite a few issues and justifies the subscription enough for me.

[A user on r/codex, 2026-10-11](https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1x2roma/reset_lended_for_day_6/pf5vuhg/)

Their setup splits the work in two. Claude makes the change, and Codex is asked what is wrong with it. That split comes up again and again in what Codex's users wrote over ten weeks, and it shows on the bench.

On Feedback Bench, Codex is 1st of 6 agents on [agent-performed code review that finds real issues](https://feedbackbench.com/coding-agents/criteria/verify.agent_code_review.md). Of its 511 rated user-weeks on that criterion, 430 are praise.

Its interval, 0.556 to 0.629, sits above the upper bound of Devin, in second, at 0.524. Devin has 33 rated user-weeks, just over the 30 a place requires, which brings the field to six. Claude Code has almost as many ratings on this criterion as Codex, 479 user-weeks, and it is 6th.

**Exhibit 1: Codex is 1st of 6 on agent-performed code review.** Feedback Bench customer love on "Agent-performed code review finds real issues", with 95% intervals, for the 6 agents with at least 30 rated user-weeks. n = rated user-weeks.

| Agent | Customer love | 95% interval | Rated user-weeks |
|---|---|---|---|
| OpenAI Codex | 0.596 | 0.556 to 0.629 | 511 |
| Devin | 0.508 | 0.489 to 0.524 | 33 |
| OpenCode | 0.499 | 0.481 to 0.516 | 37 |
| Cursor | 0.496 | 0.476 to 0.516 | 54 |
| Google Antigravity | 0.465 | 0.436 to 0.489 | 43 |
| Claude Code | 0.425 | 0.381 to 0.468 | 479 |

*31 Aug to 8 Nov 2026. Bench built 9 Nov 2026.*

OpenAI made this setup easy. Its Codex plugin for Claude Code is "for Claude Code users who want an easy way to start using Codex from the workflow they already have," and its `/codex:review` command "gives you the same quality of code review as running `/review` inside Codex directly." The docs show that the setup exists. The posts show who uses it, and where they say so.

## Claude's forums credit Codex's reviews

On Reddit, 345 people praised Codex's reviews from their own use. Of those, 157 also posted in r/ClaudeCode or r/ClaudeAI, 45.5%.

That is not just because Claude's forums are big. Among other Reddit authors who judge Codex, 9.9% (1,862 of 18,816) post in a Claude forum. Among people who praise Codex for something other than review, it is 14.3% (1,183 of 8,251). The overlap belongs to the review itself, not only to Codex users in general.

It runs the other way too, but much more weakly. Of 318 Reddit authors who praise Claude Code's reviews, 26 posted in r/codex, 8.2%, against 3.8% (696 of 18,122) of other Claude Code judges.

**Exhibit 2: Reddit authors who posted in the other agent's forum.** Share of Reddit authors. Claude forums are r/ClaudeCode and r/ClaudeAI. The baselines are all other Reddit judges. The mirror is r/codex, counted the same way.

|  | Share of Reddit authors |
|---|---|
| People who praise Codex's reviews, in a Claude forum | 45.5% (157 of 345) |
| People who praise Codex for something other than review | 14.3% (1,183 of 8,251) |
| Other Reddit authors who judge Codex | 9.9% (1,862 of 18,816) |
| People who praise Claude Code's reviews, in r/codex | 8.2% (26 of 318) |
| Other Claude Code judges | 3.8% (696 of 18,122) |

*31 Aug to 8 Nov 2026. Reddit authors only. Baselines are all other Reddit judges..*

A Claude Code user who runs client sites described the arrangement plainly:

> my main tool for development is claude code, but i actively use codex on the minimum plan - as a consultant. i mean many times i had situations when claude code during the work asked codex as a consultant and found small problems that it didn't see itself.

[A user on r/ClaudeCode, 2026-10-08](https://www.reddit.com/r/ClaudeCode/comments/1x0gwmj/newbie_question_does_anyone_use_the_claude_codex/pelwrq6/)

One r/ClaudeCode regular put the habit in a line: "[no matter how good opus 5.5 is, i always have it to do codex review via plugin](https://www.reddit.com/r/ClaudeCode/comments/1wqnjkp/be_careful_with_opus_55s_confidence/pc6sh9r/)." Another, on r/codex, kept both models and changed what Codex is for:

> i was also using codex this whole year until opus 5.5 but now i still use astra and sol 6.1 but only reviwers and researchers - they are quite good at it better than claude and opus 5.5 is stiill my main goto model

[A user on r/codex, 2026-10-13](https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1x4kfy9/things_have_really_changed_for_me/pgegj32/)

## The review sometimes sits on a small plan

A few users describe keeping a small Codex plan beside the review. OpenAI's pricing page lists "automatic code review" among the Plus plan's features. One user on two $20 plans measured a single pull request:

> the review with sol 5.6 xhigh took 12% of the 5h limit and found 3 issues. the same review with astra on light found 1 issue and took 22% of the 5h limit.

[A user on r/ClaudeCode, 2026-09-07](https://www.reddit.com/r/ClaudeCode/comments/1w9pd5z/my_claude_20_plan_is_ending_should_i_try_astra_or/p8cse0b/)

Another user, who dropped Codex to $20 "[pretty much only as a code reviewer](https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1x9rwpw/upgrade_to_pro_or_move_to_claude_20_plan/phnutky/)," added that "the reviewer is finding less and less in the opus work too." The reverse setup exists as well. One Codex-first user pays $20 for Claude because "[opus 5.5 frequently finds what sol 5.6 missed](https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1x2ad4n/best_value_for_a_20_coding_subscription/pf0rbek/)."

Those users are counting the cost by hand. OpenAI's pricing FAQ says "Code Review usage applies only when Codex runs reviews through GitHub," and that "Reviews run locally or outside of GitHub count toward your general usage limits." The plugin's readme says usage "will contribute to your Codex usage limits," and that the review gate "may drain usage limits quickly." Showing a review's expected cost before it runs, in the CLI and in the plugin, would save them the arithmetic.

## What this suggests to protect

In these posts, the reviewer is worth having because it reads another agent's work cold and finds what that agent missed. That is worth protecting as a product in its own right, next to Codex as a builder.

The plugin's tracker points the same way. Its most-reacted review request, open since 30 March, asks for a command that lets Codex "review and critique" Claude's draft plans. The posts above already include plans and specs among the things people hand Codex.

## Limits

Codex is 8th of 16 agents overall, with a Feedback Score of 48.3, and 15th of 16 on customer love, so this strength sits beside weaker readings elsewhere. The review criterion rests on 511 rated user-weeks, a small slice of Codex's posts, and Devin's second place rests on 33. r/ClaudeAI has no code-review rows in this build on or after 16 October (the last we could date is 13 October), so 157 of 345 is a low reading. The other direction is real, as the $20 Claude plan above shows, and its size is given in the forum section.

## How we read this

We started from first-hand posts about coding agents on Reddit and X from 31 August to 8 November 2026. The bench labelled each post. A place on a criterion is among agents with at least 30 rated user-weeks, ordered by customer love. Denominators in the forum split are Reddit authors only. X and store reviewers are left out, because they cannot post in a subreddit. A person counts if they praised the review criterion from their own use on Reddit. They count as posting in a Claude forum if any of their Reddit posts was in r/ClaudeCode or r/ClaudeAI, and the mirror counts a post in r/codex the same way. The baselines are all other Reddit judges, with the subreddit read from the archive; fewer than 0.6% of posts had no subreddit in the archive. The Codex review share of 45.5% (157 of 345) compares with 9.9% (1,862 of 18,816), Fisher's exact test p ≈ 4e-63, odds ratio about 7.6. The 14.3% for Codex praisers who never mention review is 1,183 of 8,251, p ≈ 2e-41, odds ratio about 5.0. For Claude Code, 8.2% against 3.8% (696 of 18,122) gives p ≈ 0.0004, odds ratio about 2.2, and against Claude Code praisers who never mention review (5.3%, 509 of 9,598) p ≈ 0.03. Every number counts all of an author's Reddit posts, and the baselines are all other Reddit judges. The mirror compares two Claude subreddits, r/ClaudeCode and r/ClaudeAI, with one Codex subreddit, r/codex. r/ClaudeAI has no review rows since 16 October. We checked every quoted sentence against the comment it links, and every quoted comment is in the bench's label file. Exhibit 1 is the bench's own reading, built 9 November 2026.

## Sources

- Feedback Bench, "Agent-performed code review finds real issues", built 9 November 2026, window 31 August to 8 November 2026
- Feedback Bench, OpenAI Codex agent page, same build
- OpenAI, Codex plugin for Claude Code, README, read 14 November 2026: [github.com/openai/codex-plugin-cc](https://github.com/openai/codex-plugin-cc)
- OpenAI, codex-plugin-cc issue 4, "Review Plan", opened 30 March 2026, still open and the most-reacted review issue when read on 14 November 2026: [github.com](https://github.com/openai/codex-plugin-cc/issues/4)
- OpenAI, Codex code review in GitHub, read 14 November 2026: [learn.chatgpt.com](https://learn.chatgpt.com/docs/third-party/github.md)
- OpenAI, Codex CLI, review command, read 14 November 2026: [learn.chatgpt.com](https://learn.chatgpt.com/docs/codex/cli)
- OpenAI, Codex pricing and FAQ, read 14 November 2026: [learn.chatgpt.com](https://learn.chatgpt.com/docs/pricing)
- r/codex, 11 October 2026: [reddit.com](https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1x2roma/reset_lended_for_day_6/pf5vuhg/)
- r/ClaudeCode, 8 October 2026: [reddit.com](https://www.reddit.com/r/ClaudeCode/comments/1x0gwmj/newbie_question_does_anyone_use_the_claude_codex/pelwrq6/)
- r/ClaudeCode, 26 September 2026: [reddit.com](https://www.reddit.com/r/ClaudeCode/comments/1wqnjkp/be_careful_with_opus_55s_confidence/pc6sh9r/)
- r/codex, 13 October 2026: [reddit.com](https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1x4kfy9/things_have_really_changed_for_me/pgegj32/)
- r/ClaudeCode, 7 September 2026: [reddit.com](https://www.reddit.com/r/ClaudeCode/comments/1w9pd5z/my_claude_20_plan_is_ending_should_i_try_astra_or/p8cse0b/)
- r/codex, 19 October 2026: [reddit.com](https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1x9rwpw/upgrade_to_pro_or_move_to_claude_20_plan/phnutky/)
- r/codex, 10 October 2026: [reddit.com](https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1x2ad4n/best_value_for_a_20_coding_subscription/pf0rbek/)
