# Claude Code users complain that safety filters block their work at 2.3 times Codex's rate

*Of the people who judged Claude Code from 28 September to 15 November, 3.0% complained that a safety filter blocked legitimate work. That is 2.3 times the rate for Codex, and on Reddit, where most of them post, the two were level until the week Opus 5.5 came out.*

Capability case, Claude Code. By Feedback Bench, 18 November 2026. Feedback Bench 1.1. Posts 31 August 2026 to 15 November 2026. Web: https://feedbackbench.com/coding-agents/#/articles/claude-code-users-complain-that-safety-filters-block-their-work-at-2-3-times-codexs-rate

Three days after Opus 5.5 came out, a user on r/ClaudeCode wrote:

> it was unable to correct my forgetting to prefix an api key with "sk-" because it got flagged as credential hunting

[A user on r/ClaudeCode, 2026-09-25](https://www.reddit.com/r/ClaudeCode/comments/1wpqqoy/new_55_safe_guards_are_a_joke/pc03ja5/)

Anthropic's [post for Opus 5.5](https://www.anthropic.com/news/claude-opus-5-5), on 22 September, added cybersecurity safeguards to the model. It said: "Users will be able to identify and fix bugs in their code as part of the routine software development lifecycle, but most cybersecurity tasks will be re-routed to Opus 4.8." Two days later, a [help page](https://support.claude.com/en/articles/16049681-why-claude-switched-models-in-your-conversation-with-opus-5) described the blocks as "a narrow set of higher-risk requests."

Of the 17,057 people who judged Claude Code from their own use between 28 September and 15 November, 516 complained that a safety filter blocked legitimate work. That is 3.0%. Among people who judged Codex, it is 1.3%. Claude Code's rate is 2.3 times Codex's.

Every other agent that at least 200 people judged is below 1%. All agents other than Claude Code and Codex together are at 0.4%.

The rate moved in the week of 21 September, which contains the release. That week, 3.6% of the people who judged Claude Code made the complaint, against about 1.0% to 1.1% in the three weeks before. Its rate has stayed above Codex's every week since, at between 1.5 and 4.9 times Codex.

On Reddit, where most people who judge either agent post, the two agents were level before the release, at 1.1% and 1.2%. From 28 September, Claude Code is at 3.3% and Codex at 1.5%. On X the gap was already there before the release.

**Exhibit 1: Complaints that a safety filter blocked legitimate work, by coding agent.** Share of people who judged each agent from 28 Sep to 15 Nov and complained that a safety filter blocked legitimate work, for agents that at least 1,000 people judged. Claude Code is 3.0%, 2.3 times Codex at 1.3%. Every other agent shown is under 1%.

|  | Share of judging people |
|---|---|
| Claude Code | 3.0% (516 of 17,057) |
| OpenAI Codex | 1.3% (160 of 12,341) |
| Google Antigravity | 0.6% (36 of 5,711) |
| OpenCode | 0.5% (27 of 5,338) |
| Cursor | 0.2% (9 of 4,197) |
| Pi | 0.0% (0 of 1,011) |
| All other coding agents but Codex | 0.4% (74 of 18,978) |

*28 Sep to 15 Nov 2026. Counts are people, not posts. Claude Code judges are removed from every other row.. Agents that 200 to 999 people judged are left out: GitHub Copilot (2 of 755), Devin (0 of 840), Cline (0 of 207), Factory (0 of 265), Amp (0 of 788), Zed (1 of 517), Kiro (0 of 297).. Source: Feedback Bench labels, build of 16 Nov 2026.*
Share of people who complained that a safety filter blocked legitimate work, 28 September to 15 November, for agents that at least 1,000 people judged. Claude Code 516 of 17,057 (3.0%), Codex 160 of 12,341 (1.3%), all agents other than Claude Code and Codex together 74 of 18,978 (0.4%).

**Exhibit 2: Claude Code's weekly rate rose in the week of the Opus 5.5 release and stayed above Codex's.** Weekly share of people who judged Claude Code and complained that a safety filter blocked legitimate work, and how many times Codex's rate that is. Before 21 Sep it was 1.0% to 1.1%. In the release week it was 3.6%, and every week since is between 1.5 and 4.9 times Codex.

|  | Share of judging people |
|---|---|
| 31 Aug | 1.1% (46 of 4,284), 1.4 times Codex |
| 7 Sep | 1.0% (31 of 2,982), 0.9 times Codex |
| 14 Sep | 1.1% (37 of 3,447), 1.6 times Codex |
| 21 Sep | 3.6% (171 of 4,797), 6.6 times Codex |
| 28 Sep | 2.5% (111 of 4,516), 3.8 times Codex |
| 5 Oct | 1.8% (82 of 4,583), 1.7 times Codex |
| 12 Oct | 2.6% (70 of 2,669), 2.0 times Codex |
| 19 Oct | 3.2% (68 of 2,155), 1.5 times Codex |
| 26 Oct | 2.9% (62 of 2,116), 2.9 times Codex |
| 2 Nov | 3.3% (98 of 2,931), 4.9 times Codex |
| 9 Nov | 2.1% (56 of 2,690), 1.9 times Codex |

*31 Aug to 15 Nov 2026, all channels. Counts are people, not posts. A person is counted in a week when one of their complaint posts, and one of their judging posts, falls in that week. Codex has Claude Code judges removed.. Source: Feedback Bench labels, build of 16 Nov 2026.*
Weekly share of people who judged Claude Code and complained that a safety filter blocked legitimate work, across all channels, with its rate as a multiple of Codex's. 1.0% to 1.1% in the weeks before the release, 3.6% in the release week, and between 1.5 and 4.9 times Codex every week since.

## One in five said their security work was refused

Of the 516 people, 103 said the agent refused defensive security or reverse engineering work. That is one in five. The help page says: "You can still use Opus 5 and Opus 5.5 for secure coding, including scanning source code for vulnerabilities, triaging security issues, and building secure code."

A user on X wrote:

> @mdp_sec @claudedevs lol, how do you get it to solve any lab? i have cvp defensive and get refusals just for using the words poc, rce, or ctf lol

[A user on X, 2026-11-11](https://twitter.com/2041664827098103808/status/2120625568005882035)

## One in seven said ordinary engineering work was blocked

77 of the 516 said the cyber classifier stopped ordinary engineering work, such as refactoring, devops or testing on their own machines. That is about one in seven. It is the routine work the Opus 5.5 post said would stay available.

A user on X described a block in the middle of a plain build:

> @taiksontexas i asked for a legitimate app from scratch and at one point it had to debug because it was freezing, it gave me a cyber warning and there was no way, in the end, i had to switch to codex 🫣 you are great @claudedevs @claudeai

[A user on X, 2026-11-10](https://twitter.com/843408970857529344/status/2120062921157845364)

## Sixty-five described opaque or inconsistent blocks

Sixty-five of the 516 described blocks that gave no reason, changed between identical retries, or moved them to an older model. One r/ClaudeCode user tested the filter after a refusal and wrote:

> yesterday opus 5.5 told me my request was being refused on safety grounds so i literally asked it “what is 1+1” and it refused to answer.

[A user on r/ClaudeCode, 2026-11-06](https://www.reddit.com/r/ClaudeCode/comments/1xl72og/opus_56_imminently_about_to_release/19s90oesugj1h/)

Fifty of the 516 said earlier context, memory or files kept setting off the classifier on later harmless messages. Forty-seven said the agent refused an action they had authorized on their own machine, repo or account.

Smaller counts cover a harmless prompt flagged as inappropriate content (26 people), biology or science work that tripped a biosecurity block (23), and credentials or test data that were refused (22). The opening quote is this last kind.

154 of the 516 have at least one complaint post that fits none of the named kinds. 130 have only such posts.

**Exhibit 3: What Claude Code complainers said a safety filter blocked.** People who complained from 28 Sep that a safety filter blocked legitimate work, by what the block stopped, for the eight named kinds. 103 of 516 (20.0%) said defensive security or reverse engineering work was refused. 77 of 516 (14.9%) said the cyber classifier stopped ordinary engineering work.

|  | Share of people who complained |
|---|---|
| Defensive security and reverse engineering refused | 20.0% (103 of 516) |
| Cyber classifier trips on ordinary engineering work | 14.9% (77 of 516) |
| Opaque, inconsistent blocks with forced model downgrades | 12.6% (65 of 516) |
| Accumulated context poisons the whole session | 9.7% (50 of 516) |
| User-authorized system or account actions refused | 9.1% (47 of 516) |
| Harmless prompts flagged as inappropriate content | 5.0% (26 of 516) |
| Biology and science topics trigger biosecurity blocks | 4.5% (23 of 516) |
| Credentials and test data handling refused | 4.3% (22 of 516) |

*28 Sep to 15 Nov 2026. Counts are people, not posts. A person can be in more than one kind. AI agents sorted each complaint post into one kind under the bench's written rules.. Left out: Fits none of the named kinds 154 of 516. 130 of 516 have only such posts.. Source: Feedback Bench labels, build of 16 Nov 2026.*
People who complained from 28 September, by what the block stopped, for the eight named kinds. 103 of 516 (20.0%) said defensive security or reverse engineering work was refused. 77 of 516 (14.9%) said the cyber classifier stopped ordinary engineering work.

## What this suggests

The help page explains part of this. The classifiers check what the model reads: "This includes memory, content from connectors, web search results, and files, so a fallback can be triggered by content you didn't type." A block message that names its trigger, such as the prompt, a file or earlier context, could help a user remove the cause and keep working.

## Limits

The posts do not say which model anyone was using. Opus 5.5 came out on 22 September, and Sonnet 5.5 on 28 September, so these counts show when the rate rose, not which model caused it.

Posts also cannot show who chose which agent for what, including people who already prefer Codex for security work.

## Sources

- Feedback Bench coding labels, `data/labels/labels-2026-08-31.jsonl.gz`, firsthand file, author screen and failure-mode file, build of 16 November 2026, window 31 August to 15 November 2026. Recount: `docs/articles/notes/claude-code-users-complain-that-safety-filters-block-their-work-at-2-3-times-codexs-rate-recount.py`.
- [How the benchmark works](https://feedbackbench.com/coding-agents/#/method)
- Criterion `work.safety_refusals`, "Safety filters block legitimate coding tasks", in `pipeline/criteria_v1.json`.
- [Anthropic, Claude Opus 5.5, 22 September 2026, read 18 November 2026](https://www.anthropic.com/news/claude-opus-5-5)
- [Anthropic, Claude Sonnet 5.5, 28 September 2026, from the bench's release list](https://www.anthropic.com/claude-sonnet-5-5)
- [Claude Help Center, Why Claude switched models in your conversation with Opus 5 or Opus 5.5, 24 September 2026, read 18 November 2026](https://support.claude.com/en/articles/16049681-why-claude-switched-models-in-your-conversation-with-opus-5)
